Review: A Natural History of Dragons by Marie Brennan

A Natural History of DragonsTitle: A Natural History of Dragons (Memoir by Lady Trent #1)

Author: Marie Brennan

Publisher: Tor Books on February 5th, 2013

Source: Bought

Rating StarRating StarRating Starstar_half

All the world, from Scirland to the farthest reaches of Eriga, know Isabella, Lady Trent, to be the world’s preeminent dragon naturalist. She is the remarkable woman who brought the study of dragons out of the misty shadows of myth and misunderstanding into the clear light of modern science. But before she became the illustrious figure we know today, there was a bookish young woman whose passion for learning, natural history, and, yes, dragons defied the stifling conventions of her day.

Here at last, in her own words, is the true story of a pioneering spirit who risked her reputation, her prospects, and her fragile flesh and bone to satisfy her scientific curiosity; of how she sought true love and happiness despite her lamentable eccentricities; and of her thrilling expedition to the perilous mountains of Vystrana, where she made the first of many historic discoveries that would change the world forever. 

As far as I’m aware, the style of A Natural History of Dragons is completely unique. It’s written as if it really were the first in a series of memoirs, with an elderly Lady Isabella Trent as the narrator of her youthful adventures. Now an established scientist and something of a national treasure, Isabella has decided – at the behest of her fans – to write about her early days as a natural scientist, before she was so highly respected.

And it took a while before that respect was afforded to her, which isn’t surprising given that A Natural History of Dragons is set in Scirland, an alternate Victorian England. I think we all know that women during that period were not to be studying ‘indelicate’ subjects like natural history, regardless of rank and individual interest. Isabella is no exception, and faces many barriers to her intellectual pursuits because of her sex. Conventional attitudes dictate that her passion for scientific study makes other peers think of her as bookish at best and a raving loony at worst.

But Isabella doesn’t care what anyone thinks, beyond her husband Jacob. Her curiosity about dragons and their anatomy must be satisfied. She is a woman possessed. A fair bit of good luck, guile, and desperation secures a position for Isabella and Jacob on an expedition to Vystrana, where they will be studying dragons in their natural habitat. Isabella swears up and down that she won’t go into the field to prevent endangering herself, but of course that lasts about two seconds. Soon she’s traipsing about the jungle, dealing with locals, smugglers, and the occasional dragon.

There are some very interesting moments between Isabella and Mr. Wilker, a brilliant lower-class scientist who’s also on the expedition. They’re pretty similar people, so of course they fight like cats and dogs. Both are brilliant scientific minds who have faced considerable censure and derision because of factors beyond their control. As someone without a title, Wilker has had to work doubly hard to ensure that he is taken seriously in scholarly circles predominantly dominated by the aristocracy. It’s through him that Isabella comes to the realization that her society limits people not just on the basis of sex, but class as well. It was nice to see her exhibit some empathy – for much of the book Isabella came off as pretty cold.

For a book titled A Natural History of Dragons there weren’t very many actual dragons in it. There are some pretty cool discoveries made about dragon kind and their anatomy, but that’s about it. It seemed like there was a lot more time spent talking about dragons than actually encountering them. There were also some things about Isabella that didn’t work for me. She’s quite dismissive of “regular” women who enjoy their lives of marriage, motherhood, and managing their households. There was an ironic kind of elitism there: Isabella is mocked and barred from scientific circles because of because of negative assumptions about female characteristics, and then she engages in this very sexism herself. She’s also pretty dismissive of one of her friends, who likes romantic stories and novels. How dare she enjoy things that aren’t about science!

Isabella may not be interested in romantic stories, but she does love her husband. Sadly Jacob was one of the least-developed secondary characters, and it seemed like he didn’t have much of a personality beyond his interest in dragons and love for Isabella. Pretty convenient, if you ask me. While I get that Victorian marriages weren’t usually love matches, I was hoping for something more than we got. If you’re going to include romance, make it a good one! My expectations were pretty low though, once I realized that elderly Isabella is Lady Trent, not Mrs. Camherst. Make of that what you will.

Overall, I thought that A Natural History of Dragons was a very creative book, but I didn’t get swept away like I thought I would. I liked Isabella and empathized with her at some points; I didn’t love her the way I wanted to. I did love Marie Brennan’s writing, though. Despite my quibbles with this one, I will happily read the next installment and recommend it to those who like biology and don’t mind a slower pace.

  • I’ve seen mixed reviews about this one and it does intrigue me-I also love the cover! I may have to pick it up at some point 🙂 Great review!

    • Thanks! 🙂 The cover art got to me too, it looks awesome on my shelf. Even though I wasn’t a huge fan, the premise is definitely enough to keep me coming back to the series. You might like it!

  • Oh I loved this book…I dunno, maybe it’s the biologist/natural sciences nut in me! But when I saw the cover and the premise of this book I knew I had to read it. I know it didn’t work for everyone though, and you brought up some very valid points. If you think there aren’t enough dragons in this one, unfortunately the next book has even less. But I do so love her world building. I think it’s really now a series less about dragons and more about her journey to study them, so there’s a lot more about her life and adventures.

    ~Mogsy

    • Thanks for letting me know about the shortage of dragons! Maybe if I’d known about that going in it wouldn’t have bothered me so much. It seems like there was a lot of character growth right at the end there, so maybe some of the issues I had with this one will be non-starters in book 2. Hopefully I’ll like that one just as much as you did!

  • I am about halfway through this one, you make some excellent points that didn’t even occur to me as possible negative things because I was hoping by the end that she would realize some of her own prejudices.

    • This seems intersting, you’ll have to tell me all about it!

      • It’s definitely a very unique book! Marie Brennan is really creative and an amazing writer to boot.

    • To be fair, she does realize some of her issues and starts treating a few people better by the end. It just felt like too little, too late to me.

  • Lisa (@TenaciousReader)

    I like the cover of this, and some of the concepts, but I am still not sure if I want to read this one. Seems like I mostly see disappointment in reviews.

    • Sometimes I wish that I wasn’t so sucked in by covers. It can cause a lot of grief sometimes.

  • The author’s distinct writing style intrigues me, and I just LOVE dragons. Even though this book did have its share of shortcomings, I think I still might have to check it out. Fab review!

    • Thanks Carmel! Dragons are definitely one of my favourite mythical creatures. If you want a kickass dragon book, you should read Seraphina by Rachel Hartman. It’s SO GOOD!